Discuss the short story A Cup of Tea by Katherine Mansfield.
Модератор: zymbronia
I have been on a close reading spree lately and reread this short story, which is much anthologized and even appears in the Bonk textbook. I assigned myself a question and wrote this short essay. If you are interested, let me know your thoughts on this story, will you? OK, here we are:
Is Rosemary Fell idealistic or materialistic?
At first glance, Rosemary demonstrates a high level of idealism. The central event of the story is that she takes pity in a beggar girl and brings her home. This charitable gesture appears to be prompted by fiction, particularly by Dostoevsky. She also seems to act out some noble principles, such as “women are sisters”. However, as we probe a bit deeper into the story, she turns out to be driven by materialism rather than idealism.
Being “not exactly beautiful”, Rosemary makes up for this by putting on artistic airs to make sure that she stands out in her circle of rich friends. She “discovers” artists and invites them to her parties. She orders around shop assistants pretending that lilac offends her artistic sensibilities. She laps on the shopkeeper’s flattery, not doubting his ridiculous claim that he would only sell his things to someone who has “that fine feeling which is so rare…” It is not a mere coincidence that in all the situations in which she shows off her artistic leanings, she also spends or is prepared to spend a lot of money. Without funding, her artistic pretensions would be exposed as illusory. Although she’s not aware of it, she relies heavily on her wealth to boost her self-image as a “brilliant” and “extremely modern” young woman.
Her urge to help the girl is not free from selfish motives, either. It is also dictated by self-promotion, as is evident from her thoughts: “…she heard herself saying afterwards to the amazement of her friends: “I simply took her home with me.”” She also derives a lot of pleasure from the girl being overwhelmed by her luxurious home.
After promising Miss Smith to take care of her, Rosemary is easily manipulated into throwing the girl out. To soften the blow, she decides to give her some money, pulls out of the drawer five pound notes and, in a telltale gesture, puts two back. She sends the girl away with three pounds, and the next thing she does is cajole her husband into letting her buy an enamel box, which costs ten times as much!
As we can see, Rosemary might be naïve and sentimental, but she lacks the strength to follow her ideals through. At the same time, the life she built for herself as well as her public persona completely depends on her wealth. Therefore, she could be considered materialistic.
Is Rosemary Fell idealistic or materialistic?
At first glance, Rosemary demonstrates a high level of idealism. The central event of the story is that she takes pity in a beggar girl and brings her home. This charitable gesture appears to be prompted by fiction, particularly by Dostoevsky. She also seems to act out some noble principles, such as “women are sisters”. However, as we probe a bit deeper into the story, she turns out to be driven by materialism rather than idealism.
Being “not exactly beautiful”, Rosemary makes up for this by putting on artistic airs to make sure that she stands out in her circle of rich friends. She “discovers” artists and invites them to her parties. She orders around shop assistants pretending that lilac offends her artistic sensibilities. She laps on the shopkeeper’s flattery, not doubting his ridiculous claim that he would only sell his things to someone who has “that fine feeling which is so rare…” It is not a mere coincidence that in all the situations in which she shows off her artistic leanings, she also spends or is prepared to spend a lot of money. Without funding, her artistic pretensions would be exposed as illusory. Although she’s not aware of it, she relies heavily on her wealth to boost her self-image as a “brilliant” and “extremely modern” young woman.
Her urge to help the girl is not free from selfish motives, either. It is also dictated by self-promotion, as is evident from her thoughts: “…she heard herself saying afterwards to the amazement of her friends: “I simply took her home with me.”” She also derives a lot of pleasure from the girl being overwhelmed by her luxurious home.
After promising Miss Smith to take care of her, Rosemary is easily manipulated into throwing the girl out. To soften the blow, she decides to give her some money, pulls out of the drawer five pound notes and, in a telltale gesture, puts two back. She sends the girl away with three pounds, and the next thing she does is cajole her husband into letting her buy an enamel box, which costs ten times as much!
As we can see, Rosemary might be naïve and sentimental, but she lacks the strength to follow her ideals through. At the same time, the life she built for herself as well as her public persona completely depends on her wealth. Therefore, she could be considered materialistic.
That's a concise way of putting it!))
-
- Сообщения: 2540
- Зарегистрирован: 11 май 2018, 09:36
- Благодарил (а): 148 раз
- Поблагодарили: 144 раза
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosemar ... aby_(film)
"she takes pity in a beggar girl " -испытывает жалость к нищенке"
"she takes pity in a beggar girl " -испытывает жалость к нищенке"
- acapnotic
- Сообщения: 3939
- Зарегистрирован: 02 мар 2018, 07:49
- Благодарил (а): 280 раз
- Поблагодарили: 925 раз
I had. But I know now what happened: I didn't think it was SO short, so I thought the texts I found to be excerpts from it. :)
Thanks for the links. But if that is all there is, I wonder how people can get so much out of it. :)
Thanks for the links. But if that is all there is, I wonder how people can get so much out of it. :)
(Sorry, I couldn't work out how to insert the name)Brevity is talent's sister? It seems she took it to the extremes. Her story looks much like "a man walks into a bar", etc. I'd expect more from a story than I would from a joke.
But that is the beauty of it!:-) You invest just a little time, but then you look into clues and the story opens up for you. It's a bit like detective work.
So, for those who want to put on their detective's hat, I have a question: What does the story tell us about Philip's character? And do you think he loves his wife?
Yes, I agree, he played on her insecurities quite spectacularly. Apart from his ability to manipulate her, are there any other indications that he is smart?He is smart and can easily make his wife do what he wants )
That's quite a profound observation ;-)Maybe one who is poor is smart enough to learn that money is vanity of vanities and vexation of spirit? )
I think, here we need to consider the historical context. It's difficult to believe that he has made this fabulous fortune himself (remember, they were very rich, not just well-off), it's more likely he inherited it. Back then, vast fortunes were rarely made in one generation (if one wasn't a pirate). And the chances are Rosemary contributed to the family's wealth. She seems to be used to big money, and, lacking in beauty and brains, how else could she attract a wealthy man?His being rich maybe. If you are so smart, why are you so poor? :)
- Yety
- Сообщения: 11198
- Зарегистрирован: 28 фев 2018, 23:44
- Благодарил (а): 3381 раз
- Поблагодарили: 5399 раз
Oh, it was even mentioned right there.)
Katherine Mansfield took a great interest in Russian literature, particularly in the works of Chekhov. In fact, she considered herself to be a pupil of the great Russian writer.
- acapnotic
- Сообщения: 3939
- Зарегистрирован: 02 мар 2018, 07:49
- Благодарил (а): 280 раз
- Поблагодарили: 925 раз
Then I'm out of ideas what else makes him look smart. I'm afraid you'll have to enlighten me on that. :)
The only guess I have, and it's a wild one, is that he had never said she was pretty in order to appear honest to her, which could have made it easier for him to deceive her in other matters.
Well, I seem to see a redundant article in #15. Can you spot it? :)
- acapnotic
- Сообщения: 3939
- Зарегистрирован: 02 мар 2018, 07:49
- Благодарил (а): 280 раз
- Поблагодарили: 925 раз
Ah, OK. Then I've probably just seen the version without the article much more often. It didn't even occur to me to look in the dictionary.
Maybe they have different meaning?
"Chances are" = "There are chances" = "It's possible".
"The chances are" = "It's likely".
Or I've been misunderstanding it all the way!
-
- Похожие темы
- Ответы
- Просмотры
- Последнее сообщение
-
- 24 Ответы
- 1646 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение Харбин Хэйлунцзян
01 июн 2019, 00:05
-
- 9 Ответы
- 1680 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение Петр Варибрус
25 сен 2018, 23:55
-
-
A Story You Want to Read: The Game )
Kind_Punk » 14 сен 2020, 21:43 » в форуме Practise Your English - 108 Ответы
- 13596 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение VictorB
20 мар 2024, 13:54
-
-
- 36 Ответы
- 3904 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение VictorB
19 окт 2020, 16:16
-
-
Advanced: a short and interesting course?!
OlgaOlga » 22 сен 2021, 12:13 » в форуме Основной педагогический форум - 15 Ответы
- 2555 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение WorkingAnt
13 окт 2021, 17:37
-
-
-
Your favorite humorous short stories and jokes
Irregardless » 22 май 2019, 13:16 » в форуме Practise Your English - 6 Ответы
- 832 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение Kind_Punk
23 май 2019, 23:31
-
-
-
Hilariuos/lighthearted short stories/novellas you'd recommend
VictorB » 26 мар 2022, 14:38 » в форуме Чтение и письмо - 16 Ответы
- 2001 Просмотры
-
Последнее сообщение VictorB
02 апр 2022, 22:22
-